I had the same problem with my IS250. Originally I’d chosen Michelin Cross Climates, but Michelin don’t do them in both sizes. Fortunately Goodyear had just launched the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 which tested very well, so I bought a set of them.
Wet weather performance is certainly on a par with the Cross Climates on our 4x4 and noise levels and ride comfort are superior to the original tyres on the Lexus. Dry road performance is also well rated. So I’m very pleased with the choice.
Rim protection might ward off the occasional kiss, but anything more passionate will mark the alloy rim, much like most tyres. So I fitted a set of Alloy Gators which directly cover the wheel rim and prevent any contact.
I hope this helps.